I replaced Apple Music with Yate, Swinsian, Navidrome, and an iPod Classic. Surprisingly better.
My ten-year experiment with Apple Music is over. Over the past month I rebuilt my workflow for managing a large local music collection; roughly 36,000 tracks. After a lot of experimentation, these are the tools that finally clicked. • Migration – Apple Music with iTunes Match ($25/year; you only need it once) • Repair – Yate (free) • Management – Swinsian ($34.95) • Maintenance – Yate + Swinsian • Consumption (hardware) – iPod Classic ($40–$400) • Consumption (streaming) – Navidrome (free) This is the story of moving from Apple Music back to files I actually own, and the workflow that makes that practical in 2026. Why Leave?Streaming trained us to tolerate a mess we never should have accepted....